In partnership with

Hi this is Ray. Today we answer a question that divides humanity into two passionate camps.

Those who insist reading is the superior, noble, scholarly path.

And those who happily listen to audiobooks while doing dishes, folding laundry, or running from the responsibilities they forgot they had.

So which is better for learning.

Reading a book or listening to it.

The answer is not simple. But it is fascinating.

Let us explore what science actually says about the differences between reading text and listening to audio, how each affects memory and comprehension, and when one format outperforms the other.

How Your Brain Processes Reading vs Listening

First, the biggest twist of all. Reading and listening activate almost the same brain regions for understanding meaning. A study from UC Berkeley demonstrated that whether participants read a story or listened to it, the same semantic networks lit up in the brain.

Link: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31427396/

So your brain extracts the meaning of the information in a very similar way.

Reading forces your brain to decode symbols.

Listening delivers pre decoded language.

The meaning lands in the same place. The work required to get there is different.

Reading requires more cognitive effort. Listening requires more cognitive trust in the narrator’s pacing.

Both forms work. But the experience changes what you remember, how deeply you process information, and how easily you can stay focused.

Receive Honest News Today

Join over 4 million Americans who start their day with 1440 – your daily digest for unbiased, fact-centric news. From politics to sports, we cover it all by analyzing over 100 sources. Our concise, 5-minute read lands in your inbox each morning at no cost. Experience news without the noise; let 1440 help you make up your own mind. Sign up now and invite your friends and family to be part of the informed.

Sign up today!

Why Reading Helps You Learn

Reading is not just absorbing words. It is a full cognitive exercise.

1. Reading improves detailed recall

A large meta analysis comparing reading comprehension and listening comprehension across 46 studies found that reading often gives learners a slight advantage in remembering small, detailed information.

Link: https://ouci.dntb.gov.ua/en/works/7qGK6zel/

Because reading lets you slow down, reread, and scan, your brain has more chances to encode fine details.

2. Reading helps with complex or technical material

If the content includes formulas, diagrams, charts, logical systems, or anything that makes your eyebrows rise involuntarily, reading usually wins. Text allows you to pause and process the complexity at your own pace.

There is no narrator rushing you along. Your brain appreciates that.

3. Reading reduces distractions

Audiobooks invite multitasking. Reading demands exclusivity.

Your brain loves exclusivity.

When fewer sensory channels compete for attention, comprehension increases.

This is why studying while listening to an audiobook is basically impossible, but reading while listening to a waterfall soundtrack makes you feel like a monk with student debt.

Why Audiobooks Help You Learn

Audiobooks are not cheating. They are a valuable learning tool with strengths that reading cannot replicate.

1. Audiobooks increase emotional engagement

A study in the Journal of Neuroscience found that listening to narratives triggers emotional processing regions in the brain more strongly than reading.

Link: https://www.jneurosci.org/content/39/41/8259

Audiobooks add tone, pacing, character voice, humor, urgency, warmth, and atmosphere. These emotional cues help you remember the story.

Narratives become more vivid and immersive when delivered through a human voice.

2. Audiobooks help auditory and language learners

Listening improves:

• pronunciation

• rhythm

• tone

• natural language flow

These qualities cannot be extracted from text alone.

3. Audiobooks offer consistent pacing

Readers naturally speed up or slow down depending on interest or fatigue. Listening enforces a controlled pace that some learners find easier to follow.

4. Audiobooks increase accessibility

Audiobooks are essential for learners with:

• dyslexia

• ADHD

• visual impairments

• reading fatigue

• cognitive load challenges

Listening removes barriers that prevent people from learning effectively.

5. Audiobooks expand learning opportunities

You can listen while:

• commuting

• cleaning

• cooking

• walking

• exercising

• hiding from your inbox

More opportunities means more learning.

Which One Is Better for Learning

The honest answer. It depends on the goal.

Reading is better for:

• Technical learning

• Memorizing facts

• Studying for quizzes and exams

• Deep thinking

• Dense theories

• Slowing down for full comprehension

Listening is better for:

• Stories

• Broad conceptual understanding

• Emotional content

• Motivational learning

• General knowledge absorption

• Learning while physically active

Neither format is superior in all cases.

Your brain is flexible.

Your goals determine the tool.

The Secret Superpower: Using Both

A 2023 systematic review analyzed whether reading while listening improves comprehension compared to reading alone. The conclusion. There is a small but meaningful benefit when people combine audio with text.

Link: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1403866.pdf

This happens because your brain encodes the information through multiple sensory pathways.

Two channels strengthen the memory trace.

Reading and listening together can:

• improve comprehension

• strengthen recall

• boost vocabulary

• increase engagement

• reduce cognitive fatigue

This is why reading along with an audiobook feels like unlocking a new skill tree in your brain.

When Audiobooks Might Outperform Reading

Audiobooks can be the better choice in several cases.

1. When your eyes are tired

Visual fatigue reduces retention. Listening keeps learning alive.

2. When the content is emotional or narrative

Narrators deliver emotional nuance that text alone cannot.

3. When you have ADHD

Audio has fewer cognitive friction points than reading.

4. When the goal is exposure, not mastery

Listening helps you move through general knowledge efficiently.

5. When your schedule is chaotic

Audiobooks turn wasted time into learning time.

When Reading Might Outperform Audiobooks

Reading wins when precision is necessary.

1. When studying for exams

You need to highlight, underline, annotate, review.

2. When the content includes visuals

Diagrams do not translate well to audio.

3. When deep comprehension is required

Reading allows controlled pacing and reprocessing.

The Real Factor: Engagement, Not Format

Most people ask which format is better. But the real determinant of learning is engagement.

If you read distracted, comprehension drops. If you listen distracted, comprehension drops.

What matters is:

• attention

• pacing

• emotional connection

• interest

• review

• repetition

Audiobooks and reading can both produce powerful learning when used with intention.

Ray’s Practical Guide for Choosing the Right Format

Ask yourself one question:

“Do I need deep mastery or solid understanding?”

If you need mastery. Read.

If you need understanding. Listen.

If you want both. Combine them.

And if you want to feel productive while avoiding chores. I recommend audiobooks. They pair beautifully with dishwashing and existential dread.

Stay curious,

Ray