Cognitive Flexibility: How to Think Like a Scientist (and Learn Like One)

In partnership with

Hi, this is Ray.

Here’s something I probably shouldn’t admit: I used to think being stubborn meant being smart.

If I believed something, I held onto it like a bulldog guarding a chew toy.

Then I realized half the things I was sure about in my twenties turned out to be wrong, including my haircut choices.

That’s when I discovered the concept of cognitive flexibility, your brain’s ability to shift between ideas, adapt to change, and learn from mistakes instead of clinging to them.

In other words, it’s how scientists think. They don’t defend old beliefs; they test them. And that mindset might just be the single most important skill for learning in the modern world.

What Is Cognitive Flexibility?

Cognitive flexibility is the ability to adjust your thinking when faced with new information or unexpected situations.

Psychologists call it a core executive function, part of the brain’s control system that handles switching tasks, perspectives, or problem-solving strategies.

A study from the University of Cambridge found that cognitive flexibility predicts how well people adapt to new environments and learn complex skills.

In plain English: flexible thinkers learn faster, forget slower, and panic less when plans change.

Read newsletters, not spam

Tired of newsletters vanishing into Gmail’s promotion tab — or worse, being buried under ad spam?

Proton Mail keeps your subscriptions organized without tracking or filtering tricks. No hidden tabs. No data profiling. Just the content you signed up for, delivered where you can actually read it.

Built for privacy and clarity, Proton Mail is a better inbox for newsletter lovers and information seekers alike.

Newsletters without the noise

The Brain Science Behind Flexibility

Cognitive flexibility happens mainly in the prefrontal cortex, the part of your brain responsible for planning, reasoning, and self-control.

When you’re stuck in rigid thinking, this area quiets down. When you’re open to alternatives, it lights up.

A study from the University of Oxford showed that people with more active prefrontal networks during problem-solving learned new patterns twice as fast as those with less activity.

It’s literally your brain’s agility workout.

The catch? The more stress or certainty you feel, the less flexible your thinking becomes. That’s why tight deadlines and strong opinions both make learning harder.

The Flexibility Paradox

We all like to think of ourselves as open-minded. Yet the more expertise we gain, the more rigid our thinking can become.

Psychologists call this the Einstellung effect, when past experience blinds you to better solutions.

A study from the University of Chicago found that experts often perform worse on creative problem-solving tasks than beginners because their brains default to familiar patterns.

In short, being good at something can make you bad at learning something new.

The solution isn’t to forget your knowledge, but to question it more often.

How to Train Cognitive Flexibility

Flexibility isn’t just a trait. It’s a trainable skill. And like stretching before a workout, it gets easier the more you practice.

Here’s how to build it.

1. Challenge Your First Answer

The moment you think you’ve got something figured out, stop and ask, “What else could be true?”

This simple habit disrupts the brain’s tendency to lock onto the first available explanation.

A study from Duke University found that participants who deliberately considered multiple explanations made better decisions and learned faster.

In learning, curiosity beats confidence every time.

2. Mix Up Learning Methods

If you always study the same way, your brain gets lazy.

Alternate between reading, watching, writing, and teaching. Each mode activates different neural pathways, improving flexibility and retention.

A study from the University of California, Irvine found that multimodal learning increases brain plasticity and adaptability, especially when switching formats regularly.

Think of it as cross-training for your neurons.

3. Seek Disconfirming Evidence

Scientists don’t look for proof that they’re right. They look for proof that they’re wrong.

Adopting that mindset in everyday learning builds resilience and humility.

A study from Stanford University showed that people who practiced scientific reasoning, forming hypotheses, testing them, and revising based on feedback, improved comprehension across subjects.

Try it yourself: when you learn something, ask, “What evidence would change my mind?”

4. Rotate Between Tasks

Instead of grinding one topic for hours, rotate between related subjects. This interleaving keeps your brain agile and prevents mental fatigue.

A study from the University of South Florida found that interleaving improved long-term retention and transfer across disciplines.

Switching gears isn’t distraction; it’s flexibility training.

5. Reframe Mistakes as Data

Every failure contains feedback if you’re flexible enough to see it.

A study from the University of Michigan discovered that people who reframed errors as information activated brain areas linked to growth and learning, while those who avoided thinking about mistakes didn’t improve.

Mistakes aren’t setbacks; they’re calibration points.

The Link Between Flexibility and Creativity

The best learners and the best creators have one thing in common: they both rely on flexibility.

A study from the University of Amsterdam found a direct correlation between cognitive flexibility and divergent thinking, the ability to come up with multiple solutions to a problem.

In other words, creative people aren’t just imaginative, they’re mentally adaptable. They can hold conflicting ideas without exploding.

This is why scientists often make great artists, and vice versa. They practice thinking that bends but doesn’t break.

My Experiment: 30 Days of Contradictions

A few years ago, I tried an experiment. For one month, I made myself read opinions I disagreed with.

Every day, I’d pick a topic, business, politics, education, even pineapple on pizza, and read both sides.

At first, it was infuriating. My brain wanted to yell, “That’s wrong!” But after a week, I started to see nuance. I understood why people thought differently, and my own arguments got sharper.

I wasn’t losing conviction. I was gaining perspective.

By the end of the month, I noticed the same skill showing up everywhere, in conversations, in learning, even in strategy meetings. I wasn’t reacting anymore. I was responding.

Turns out, cognitive flexibility doesn’t just make you smarter. It makes you calmer.

The Bigger Lesson: Certainty Is the Enemy of Growth

Rigid minds break under change. Flexible minds grow from it.

In a world where knowledge doubles every few years, adaptability matters more than memorization.

The best learners think like scientists. They form hypotheses, test them, stay curious, and change their minds when the data demands it.

So the next time you feel certain, pause. Ask yourself what would make you reconsider. Because in learning, the strongest mind isn’t the one that knows the most, it’s the one that can bend without breaking.

Stay curious,

Ray