Metacognition: How to Think About Your Own Thinking

In partnership with

Hi, this is Ray.

I once spent an entire weekend trying to learn how to play the "Imperial March" on a ukulele. By Sunday afternoon, I was frustrated, my fingers were sore, and I sounded less like Darth Vader and more like a dying cat in a wind chime factory.

Eventually, I stopped practicing and asked myself a dangerous question: "Why am I still bad at this?" I realized I was just repeating the same three chords over and over, hoping they would magically get better. I wasn't actually monitoring my progress; I was just on autopilot. I was "doing," but I wasn't "thinking about the doing."

In the LSQ framework, this is the "Overlord" phase. It’s called Metacognition. If your brain is a computer, metacognition is the operating system that monitors all the other programs. It’s the ability to step outside yourself and observe your own learning process. Today, we’re going to look at why this "mental mirror" is the single most important skill you can develop for long-term success.

The headlines that actually moves markets

Tired of missing the trades that actually move markets?

Every weekday, you’ll get a 5-minute Elite Trade Club newsletter covering the top stories, market-moving headlines, and the hottest stocks — delivered before the opening bell.

Whether you’re a casual trader or a serious investor, it’s everything you need to know before making your next move.

Join 200K+ traders who read our 5-minute premarket report to see which stocks are setting up for the day, what news is breaking, and where the smart money’s moving.

Click Here to Join Now

^{_{By joining, you’ll receive Elite Trade Club emails and select partner insights. See Privacy Policy.}}

The Two Pillars of Metacognition

Metacognition is generally broken down into two parts: Metacognitive Knowledge (what you know about how you learn) and Metacognitive Regulation (how you use that knowledge to adjust your strategy).

Think of it like a game of Civilization. Metacognitive Knowledge is knowing that your civilization is low on gold. Metacognitive Regulation is deciding to stop building cathedrals and start building markets to fix the problem.

Most learners are like a civilization with no UI… they’re running out of resources, but they don't even know where to look to see the stats. According to a study in Educational Psychologist, students with high metacognitive skills significantly outperform those with higher IQs but lower metacognitive awareness. It’s not about how "fast" your processor is; it’s about how well you manage the tasks it's running.

Strategy 1: The "Self-Correction" Loop (Monitoring)

The biggest mistake we make in learning is assuming that "familiarity" equals "mastery." This is why we reread notes instead of testing ourselves. Metacognition forces you to break that illusion.

One of the most effective tools for this is Calibration. This is the practice of predicting how well you know something before you see the answer.

• Before you check the back of the book, ask: "On a scale of 1-10, how sure am I that I can solve this?"

• If you say "10" and you get it wrong, you have a calibration error.

Research on Monitoring Accuracy published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology shows that the better you are at predicting your own performance, the more efficiently you can allocate your study time. If you know exactly what you don't know, you stop wasting time on the stuff you’ve already mastered.

Strategy 2: Heuristics and Mental Checklists (Regulation)

High-level learners don't just "start" a task. They have a pre-game ritual. They ask:

1. "What is the goal of this session?"

2. "What strategies have worked for me on similar tasks in the past?"

3. "What are the potential distractions I need to avoid?"

This is "Task Analysis." A meta-analysis on metacognitive strategies found that learners who explicitly plan their approach and evaluate their progress at intervals show much higher retention rates.

When I’m learning a new coding language, I don't just "code." I set a timer for 30 minutes and tell myself: "If I haven't solved this bug in 10 minutes, I will stop and look for a different analogy or resource." I am regulating my frustration before it even happens.

Strategy 3: The Post-Mortem (Evaluating)

After a study session or an exam, most people just want to throw their books in a fire and forget the experience ever happened. But the "Post-Mortem" is where the real growth happens.

Ask yourself:

• "Which part of my strategy worked best?"

• "Where did I lose focus?"

• "What would I do differently if I had to learn this again from scratch?"

This is called Reflective Thinking. It turns every failure into a "patch" for your mental software. You aren't just learning the material; you’re learning how to be a better learner.

Why We Struggles with "Auto-Pilot"

My biggest metacognitive fail is the "I’ll just do one more" trap. I’ll be exhausted, my brain will be "lagging," and my comprehension will be at zero. A "metacognitive" person would say: "Ray, your hardware is overheated. Go sleep."

But the "Auto-Pilot" Ray says: "No! We must finish the chapter!"

I’ve had to train myself to check my "Mental Battery" every hour. If I find myself reading the same paragraph three times, I have to be smart enough to admit that my current strategy (reading) is no longer working for my current state (exhausted).

The Metacognition "System Check"

Next time you feel stuck, run this diagnostic:

1. The Goal Check: What exactly am I trying to achieve in the next 20 minutes?

2. The Strategy Check: Is "reading more" actually the best way to solve this confusion, or should I draw a diagram?

3. The Feeling Check: Am I frustrated? If so, why? (Is the task too hard, or am I just tired?)

Final Thought

Metacognition is the difference between being a "student" and being a "master." A student waits to be told what they don't know. A master is constantly probing the edges of their own ignorance.

You don't need a higher IQ to learn better. You just need a better mirror. Stop being the program, and start being the programmer.

I’m going to go evaluate why I still can’t play the ukulele properly. I suspect it involves my "refusal to practice scales" strategy, but I’ll let my metacognition confirm that.

Stay self-aware and keep upgrading your OS.

Ray