The AI trap: Convenience vs. Competence

In partnership with

Hi, this is Ray.

I recently found myself in a bit of a "digital pickle." I was trying to write a complex bit of code for a personal project, and instead of wrestling with the logic (you know, that fun part where your brain feels like it’s doing a set of heavy deadlifts) I just asked an AI to do it for me. It worked. The code ran. I felt like a productivity god.

But two days later, when I needed to tweak that same code? I was completely lost. I had the "Output," but I didn't have the "Understanding." I had outsourced the struggle, and in doing so, I had accidentally deleted the learning.

We’ve talked about using AI as a "Co-Processor." But there is a dark side. If you aren't careful, AI can actually trump the learning process (pun intended, because I'm a dork). Today, we’re looking at the science of Cognitive Offloading and why the "Easy Path" often leads to a hollowed-out brain.

The Problem of Cognitive Offloading

Your brain is the ultimate energy miser. If it thinks it can get a result without spending the glucose to "think," it will take that shortcut every single time. This is called Cognitive Offloading.

When we use AI to summarize a book, write an essay, or solve a problem for us, we are bypassing the "Encoding" process. Research published in Nature Reviews Psychology suggests that while offloading can free up mental resources, it often leads to "offloading-related forgetting." If you don't use your biological RAM to process the info, your brain doesn't bother creating a "Save File" in long-term memory.

The "Illusion of Explanatory Depth" on Steroids

We’ve talked about the "Illusion of Explanatory Depth" before… the feeling that we understand something just because we are familiar with it. AI makes this ten times worse.

When an AI gives you a perfect, polished explanation of a topic, it feels so clear that you assume you’ve mastered it. But this is Passive Consumption disguised as Understanding. A study on the impact of Generative AI in education warns that over-reliance on AI-generated content can lead to a "knowledge gap" where students can produce high-quality work without actually possessing the underlying skills.

You become a "Prompt Engineer" but a "Knowledge Pauper." You're like a pilot who only knows how to use autopilot; the moment the system glitches, you're in trouble.

Did you know 1 in 3 women have a chronic hormonal condition?

Allara helps women understand their health without the guesswork.

Most women experience treating symptoms like stubborn weight, fatigue, and irregular cycles in silos with a fragmented care experience. But your body and your healthcare shouldn't work that way.

At Allara, they close the gap between symptoms and solutions with a unified clinical approach. Allara's care team, made up of medical leaders and expert registered dietitians, partner to devise a treatment plan using advanced diagnostic testing and each patient's unique health history to address what the body needs: optimizing metabolic markers, balancing hormones, or both simultaneously. Whether you’re managing PCOS, insulin resistance, thyroid conditions, perimenopause, or a complex overlap of concerns, Allara treats root causes instead of chasing individual symptoms.

Allara offers personalized, evidence-based care that evolves with you over time – all accessible virtually and covered by insurance. You'll work with an expert team throughout your journey, adjusting your plan as your body and needs change, so you can finally feel like yourself again.

Get started with Allara

Why "The Struggle" is the Signal

The most important takeaway from neurobiology is this: The struggle is the learning. When you find a concept difficult, your brain releases neuromodulators like acetylcholine and norepinephrine. These chemicals signal to your neurons that "this is important… change the wiring!" According to Dr. Robert Bjork’s theory of Desirable Difficulties, if the learning feels easy, you aren't building "Storage Strength."

AI is a "Friction-Killer." By removing the struggle, it removes the biological signal for your brain to grow. If you use AI to bypass the "hard parts," you are essentially paying for a gym membership and then hiring someone else to lift the weights for you. You might have the "result" (a completed task), but you won't have the "muscle" (the skill).

How to Avoid the "AI Lobotomy"

I still use AI, but I’ve changed how I use it. I treat it like a "Spotter" at the gym, not a "Replacement" for the workout.

• The 15-Minute Rule: I never ask an AI for help until I have struggled with a problem on my own for at least 15 minutes. This ensures my brain has already released the "change the wiring" chemicals.

• The "Show Your Work" Prompt: Instead of asking for the answer, I ask: "Explain the logic of how to solve this, but don't give me the final result yet."

• The Post-AI Quiz: After AI helps me understand something, I close the window and try to recreate the logic from scratch using Active Recall.

Why I "Argue" with the AI

I’ve started intentionally trying to find mistakes in what the AI tells me. I’ll ask it to explain a concept, and then I’ll hunt for nuances it missed or oversimplified. This forces me back into Metacognition (thinking about the thinking).

If you just nod along to whatever the AI says, you’re an NPC. If you challenge it, you’re the Main Character.

Your "Anti-Offloading" Protocol

1. Struggle First: Never use AI as your first step. Use it as your third or fourth.

2. Verify the Source: AI can "hallucinate" (make stuff up with total confidence). Always check the "Lore" against a primary source.

3. Synthesis Over Summary: Don't ask for a summary of a book. Read the book, write your own summary, and ask the AI to find the "Gaps" in your logic.

4. The "Closed-Book" Test: After using AI for help, can you explain the concept to a friend without looking at the screen? If not, you haven't learned it.

Final Thought

AI is a tool, and like any tool, it can be used to build a palace or accidentally cut your thumb off. Don't let the convenience of the "Now" rob you of the competence of the "Future." Use the technology to sharpen your brain, not to replace it.

I’m off to go rewrite that bit of code from scratch. My brain is groaning already, which means I’m actually making progress.

Stay sharp and keep the struggle alive.

Ray