Why Multitasking Is a Lie (and How to Reclaim Focus)

In partnership with

Hi, this is Ray.

Let’s start with an uncomfortable truth. You’re not multitasking right now. You’re task-switching really fast and pretending it’s the same thing.

I used to think I was a productivity superhero. I’d answer emails, edit videos, and check analytics while on Zoom calls, all while telling myself, “I’m being efficient.” What I was actually being was distracted, frazzled, and halfway terrible at everything.

Science has spoken: multitasking is a myth. Your brain can’t focus on more than one complex task at a time. When you try, it just flips attention between them, losing energy, accuracy, and memory along the way.

Let’s break down why multitasking destroys learning and how to rebuild the deep focus your brain was designed for.

The Multitasking Myth

First, the good news: you can walk and chew gum. Your brain handles simple, automatic actions together without breaking a sweat.

But when it comes to complex cognitive work, the kind needed for studying, reasoning, or creating, you only have one spotlight of attention. It can point at one thing at a time. Every time you switch tasks, your brain has to turn off one set of mental circuits and activate another.

A Stanford study found that people who think they’re great multitaskers are actually worse at filtering distractions, worse at recalling information, and worse at switching between tasks. In other words, the more you multitask, the worse your brain gets at multitasking.

It’s like going to the gym to work out your legs and leaving with noodle arms.

The Cost of Task Switching

Every time you switch tasks, your brain pays a toll. Psychologists call this switching cost, and it’s not small.

A study from the American Psychological Association found that switching between tasks can reduce productivity by up to 40%. The brain takes seconds to reorient itself every time you move from one activity to another.

Those seconds add up. If you’re constantly bouncing between apps, emails, and study materials, you’re wasting hours of potential focus without realizing it.

Even worse, switching creates attention residue, a concept coined by Sophie Leroy at the University of Minnesota. Her research shows that when you move from Task A to Task B, part of your attention stays stuck on Task A. Your brain is still mentally chewing on it. That’s why you reread the same line of a book three times after checking your phone.

Your brain can’t let go that fast. It needs a clean break, not a quick hop.

The Daily Newsletter for Intellectually Curious Readers

Join over 4 million Americans who start their day with 1440 – your daily digest for unbiased, fact-centric news. From politics to sports, we cover it all by analyzing over 100 sources. Our concise, 5-minute read lands in your inbox each morning at no cost. Experience news without the noise; let 1440 help you make up your own mind. Sign up now and invite your friends and family to be part of the informed.

Join for free today!

Why Multitasking Destroys Learning

Learning requires what psychologists call working memory, the limited space where your brain holds and manipulates information. It’s like your mind’s “RAM.”

When you multitask, you overload that RAM. Cognitive load theory, developed by psychologist John Sweller, shows that your brain has a finite capacity for processing information. Once that capacity is full, learning collapses.

A study from the University of London found that people who multitasked during cognitive tests scored lower IQs than those who were high from marijuana. Yes, multitasking literally made them dumber than being stoned.

Multitasking doesn’t just slow learning; it sabotages memory. A University of California study found that people who switched between tasks remembered less information and had more trouble transferring it into long-term memory.

So if you’re studying with Netflix in the background or checking texts every five minutes, you’re basically learning how to forget.

Why You Feel Productive While Multitasking

Here’s the psychological trick: multitasking feels productive because you’re busy. You’re getting little hits of dopamine every time you check off a micro-task or refresh a feed.

That’s why apps are designed to keep you switching; it’s addictive. A Harvard Business Review article explains that novelty releases dopamine, which makes us feel good, even when it’s wrecking our focus. Your brain gets addicted to the feeling of doing lots of things, even if none of them matter.

That’s also why deep work feels uncomfortable at first. It’s not as stimulating. But once you push past the initial boredom, focus turns into flow, and your brain starts performing at its peak.

Reclaiming Your Focus

So how do you fix your multitasking habit without moving to a cave or throwing your phone into a volcano?

1. One Tab Rule

Keep only one tab or app open when working or studying. If you need something else, write it down and come back later. The act of switching tabs is often the cue that breaks concentration.

2. The Pomodoro Technique (With a Twist)

Set a 25-minute timer for pure focus, then take a 5-minute break. But during the break, don’t touch your phone. Let your mind wander instead. This rest period lets your brain’s default mode network integrate what you just learned.

3. Set “Context Blocks”

Group similar tasks together. Respond to all emails at once, then switch to research, then writing. Each type of work uses different mental muscles. Switching between them too often is like trying to sprint and knit at the same time.

4. Notifications Are the Enemy

Even small interruptions kill focus. A study from the University of California, Irvine found it takes over 23 minutes to regain full concentration after a notification. Silence them all. If it’s truly urgent, they’ll call twice.

5. Practice “Monotasking”

Pick one activity and give it your full attention. Cooking, reading, exercising, even watching a movie counts. Training your brain to focus in daily life builds the same neural strength you need for deep study.

6. Create Rituals for Focus

Your brain loves cues. Light a candle, play the same instrumental playlist, or study in a consistent spot. These small rituals signal to your brain, “It’s focus time.” Over time, the association kicks in automatically.

The Power of Deep Focus

When you stop multitasking, something incredible happens. Your brain starts entering deep work, a concept popularized by Cal Newport. In deep work, you’re fully immersed, pushing your limits, and producing at your highest potential.

In this state, your brain literally changes. A study in NeuroImage found that sustained attention increases gray matter density in areas linked to learning and memory. In other words, the more you focus, the smarter your brain gets.

You also experience flow, that sweet spot where time disappears and effort feels effortless. Learning becomes enjoyable again, not just effective.

My Personal Experiment: The 3-Week Focus Detox

Last year, I tried going three weeks without multitasking. No phone during work blocks. No checking messages mid-task. One window open at a time.

The first few days were awful. My brain craved stimulation like caffeine. But by week two, something clicked. My work sessions felt calmer. My recall improved. I could actually remember what I read. And I finished projects faster than before.

The strangest part? I felt less tired. Multitasking drains your mental battery faster than you realize. Deep focus, on the other hand, gives energy back.

Now, I still slip sometimes. But every time I catch myself juggling tasks, I remember that study comparing multitasking to being high, and that’s usually enough motivation to close the extra tab.

The Bigger Lesson: Focus Is the New Superpower

In a world that rewards busyness, focus is rebellion.

Your ability to focus deeply is now rarer and more valuable than ever. It’s how you learn faster, create better, and stand out in a distracted world.

Multitasking is not a skill. It’s a trap that trades depth for distraction.

So if you want to learn faster, remember more, and actually enjoy the process, give your attention to one thing at a time. That’s how real mastery is built.

Stay curious,

Ray