Why Your Brain Learns Better When You Stop Being a Sponge

In partnership with

Hi, this is Ray,

And yes, I'm writing this from my kitchen table, surrounded by half-wrapped holiday gifts and the existential dread of wondering if anyone actually wants the stuff I bought them. But while procrastinating on gift-wrapping, I stumbled into something way more interesting than ribbon techniques: why most of us are studying completely wrong.

Here's the thing: We've all been taught that learning is about absorbing information. Read it. Highlight it. Read it again. Maybe write some notes if you're feeling fancy. It's like our brains are supposed to work like sponges... soak it all up, wring it out on test day, and boom: knowledge.

Except... that's not how brains actually work.

And if you're like me and have ever spent three hours "studying" only to blank completely when you need the info, you know exactly what I'm talking about.

So what's the secret? Active retrieval. And no, that's not some tech startup buzzword. It's legitimately one of the most powerful learning strategies backed by decades of research... that somehow no one told us about in school.

Let me explain.

The Problem With Being a Passive Learner

Let's start with what most of us do when we "study."

We:

• Reread our notes

• Highlight textbooks (in three different colors if we're overachievers)

• Watch lecture videos

• Make pretty study guides

• Occasionally panic-scroll through Quizlet at 2 AM

This is called passive learning. You're letting information wash over you like a gentle educational rain. Passive learning relies on instructor-centered methods where you absorb information through rereading or highlighting, often creating only a surface-level understanding.

And here's the brutal truth: Passive learning creates an illusion of knowledge, making you think you're familiar with material just because you've been exposed to it multiple times.

You know that feeling when something seems familiar during review, so you think you've got it? Yeah. That's your brain lying to you.

The headlines that actually moves markets

Tired of missing the trades that actually move markets?

Every weekday, you’ll get a 5-minute Elite Trade Club newsletter covering the top stories, market-moving headlines, and the hottest stocks — delivered before the opening bell.

Whether you’re a casual trader or a serious investor, it’s everything you need to know before making your next move.

Join 200K+ traders who read our 5-minute premarket report to see which stocks are setting up for the day, what news is breaking, and where the smart money’s moving.

Click Here to Join Now

^{_{By joining, you’ll receive Elite Trade Club emails and select partner insights. See Privacy Policy.}}

Enter: The Testing Effect (Or Why Quizzing Yourself Is Magic)

Now for the good news.

There's a learning method so effective that it's been studied in hundreds of research papers. A meta-analysis of 159 studies found that 81% showed a positive benefit on subsequent recall compared to simple exposure.

It's called retrieval practice, and it works like this: Instead of passively reviewing information, you actively try to pull it out of your brain. No peeking. No hints. Just you vs. your memory.

Think:

• Flashcards (but actually trying to recall before flipping)

• Practice tests

• Writing down everything you remember about a topic

• Explaining concepts out loud to your cat (who will judge you, but it works)

The research is wild. Students who practiced active retrieval retained information better long-term than those who repeatedly reread material, even though they spent the same amount of time studying.

Even weirder: Students who repeatedly read material believed they learned it better, but their actual learning showed the opposite pattern. Our intuition about what helps us learn is... completely backwards.

Why Does This Work?

Here's the neuroscience part (don't worry, I'll keep it brief):

Every time you actively retrieve information from memory, you're not just testing what you know... you're actually strengthening that knowledge. Retrieval actively contributes to learning, changing and improving knowledge each time it's recalled.

It's like your brain is laying down a hiking trail. The more you walk that path (retrieve that memory), the clearer and faster the trail becomes.

Passive review? That's like looking at a map of the trail. Sure, you're aware of it. But you're not actually building the pathway.

And here's the kicker: The more difficult the retrieval, the better for long-term learning, even though struggling to recall makes you feel like you're doing poorly.

That uncomfortable feeling when you can't quite remember something? That's your brain actually learning. Embrace the suck.

Active Learning vs. Sitting There Looking Pretty

Now, this isn't just about flashcards. The whole concept extends to active learning versus passive learning in general.

A review of 225 undergraduate science studies concluded that active learning methods produced a general improvement of 6% on examinations compared to passive methods.

Six percent might not sound like much, but that's the difference between a B+ and an A-, or between passing and failing if you're on the edge.

Active learning includes:

• Teaching the material to someone else (even if it's your dog)

• Creating concept maps

• Solving problems

• Discussing ideas with classmates

• Making up your own test questions

Passive learning includes:

• Sitting in lectures and zoning out

• Rereading the same paragraph five times while thinking about lunch

• Highlighting everything (which is basically highlighting nothing)

• Watching videos without pausing to process

See the difference? One makes your brain work. The other lets your brain coast.

The Holiday Learning Paradox

Now here's where I tie this back to the holidays (because apparently I'm writing this instead of gift-wrapping).

Think about how we actually learn during the holidays:

You don't learn to cook your grandma's famous pie recipe by reading it five times. You learn by doing it... probably screwing it up the first time... then actively recalling what went wrong and adjusting.

You don't learn the rules of that new board game your family got by passively reading the instructions. You learn by playing it, making mistakes, and actively figuring out the strategy.

We instinctively use active learning in real life. We just forget to apply it when we're sitting at a desk with a textbook.

Holiday Gift Ideas That Actually Support Learning

Alright, since we're on the topic of holidays AND learning... here are some gift ideas for the students in your life that align with active learning principles:

For the College Student:

• A whiteboard for their room (seriously, explaining concepts on a whiteboard = retrieval practice gold)

• Anki Pro subscription (flashcard app that uses spaced repetition)

• Noise-canceling headphones (because active learning requires actual focus)

For the High School Student:

• A journal for "brain dumps" (writing everything they know about a topic)

• A timer for Pomodoro studying sessions

• Study group snacks (active learning works better with others)

For the Lifelong Learner:

• Duolingo Super (language learning through active practice)

• A course on something they've wanted to learn (pottery, coding, whatever)

• A set of blank flashcards (old school, but effective)

For Yourself (Because You Deserve It):

• Time. Block off actual time to practice active retrieval.

• Permission to struggle. Remember: if it feels hard, you're probably learning.

• A study buddy. Someone to quiz you or listen to your explanations.

How to Actually Do This

Okay, enough theory. Here's how to implement active retrieval:

1. After reading a chapter: Close the book. Write down everything you remember. Don't peek. Feel dumb. Then check what you missed.

2. Make flashcards the right way: Write a question on one side. Try to answer it BEFORE flipping. If you flip immediately, you're wasting your time.

3. Use the Feynman Technique: Explain the concept out loud like you're teaching a five-year-old. If you can't, you don't really understand it.

4. Create practice tests: Don't wait for the real test. Make up questions and answer them. Bonus: you'll probably guess what's on the actual test.

5. Study in different places: This actually helps with retrieval because your brain builds more pathways to the information (throwback to my article about study locations).

6. Space it out: Don't cram. Retrieval practice enhanced long-term learning by more than one standard deviationcompared to elaborate studying methods like concept mapping. But you need to practice retrieval over time, not all at once.

The Uncomfortable Truth

Here's what nobody wants to hear: Active learning is harder than passive learning.

It's easier to reread notes than to quiz yourself. It's more comfortable to highlight than to struggle with recall. It's less stressful to watch a Khan Academy video than to work through a problem yourself.

But easier doesn't mean better.

When information comes to mind easily, it's actually easier to forget, while effortful retrieval creates the best long-term learning.

Your brain is a muscle. And just like you can't get stronger by watching workout videos on your couch, you can't get smarter by passively soaking up information.

To Recap:

• Passive learning (rereading, highlighting) = illusion of knowledge

• Active retrieval (quizzing yourself, explaining concepts) = actual learning

• Your brain lies to you: if it feels easy, you're probably not learning

• The struggle is the point: difficult retrieval = stronger memory

• Apply it everywhere: the holidays are full of active learning opportunities

• Gift idea bonus: give the gift of effective learning tools

Final Thoughts

Look, I'm not going to tell you to throw out all your highlighters and burn your study guides. Sometimes passive learning has its place... like getting a basic overview of a topic or initial exposure to new information.

But if you want to actually remember what you're studying... if you want to stop blanking on tests when you swearyou studied... if you want to feel like your time spent learning is actually productive...

Stop being a sponge. Start being a retriever.

Your brain (and your GPA) will thank you.

Now if you'll excuse me, I have some holiday gifts to wrap. And yes, I'll probably learn gift-wrapping through active practice (i.e., screwing it up multiple times) rather than watching tutorials.

Happy holidays, and happy learning,

Ray

P.S. If you're reading this during holiday break, please don't actually study. Take a break. Your brain needs rest too. Active retrieval works best when you're not burned out.